Open for Lunch and Dinner

6 Days a week

Closed Wednesdays


Call us AT:


email us AT:





Soup of the Day  4.95/6.95
Montauk Fish Chowder (Bowl)  8.95
Ceasar Salad  8.95
Add Chicken  $4.95  Add Shrimp $6.95
Chili with the Works  10.95
Raw Red Onion, Cheese, Sour Cream and Chips
Hot Pot Roast Sandwich with French Fries and Gravey  14.95
Panko Crusted Fish and Chips with Hand Cut
Fries and Cole Slaw  17.95
Turkey BLT – Turkey, Lettuce and Tomato on a Kaiser Roll with French Fries  14.95
Broiled Flounder Scampi Style with Rice and Vegetables  18.95
Corn Beef Ruben – Corn Beef on Toasted Rye Bread with Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut and Russian Dressing served with Hand Cut Fries and Cole Slaw  17.95

Have You Tried Sammy’s Lobster Burger Yet?

Sammys is open now for Lunch and Dinner Thursday thru Sunday 

We have Daily Specials !

Lunch Specials

What's Happening...

Restaurant and Bar

448 West Lake Dr

Montauk, NY 11954

Sammy's Grab and Go Poke Window is Open!!!

​Sammy has great new Drinks too!​


Cod Cakes with Homemade Tartar Sauce  $10.95
Curly Shrimp with Bang Bang Sriracha Sauce   $12.95
Crispy Avocado with Lemon Rocket Salad   $12.95
Fried Shishito Peppers with Aioli   $10.95
*Poke – Fresh Tuna with Soyu Ginger Sauce, Seaweed Salad and Cucumbers in a Wonton Crisp with Spicy Sriracha Drizzle and Green Onions    $12.95
Bowl of Montauk Fish Chowder $8.95


 Fried Chicken Breast over Waffles with Country Gravy and Cole Slaw  $21.95
Catch of the Day
Grilled Lobster Tails with Lobster & Seafood Stuffing with
 Pesto Potatoes and Fresh Vegetables   $27.95  
Fisherman’s Platter – Golden Fried Flounder, Clams and Shrimp served with fresh cut French Fries and Cole Slaw   $24.95
Buttered Lobster Roll – Chunks of Lobster Meat with Drawn Butter on a Toasted Buttered Roll and served with Fresh Cut French Fries and Cole Slaw   $24.95

Nightly Dinner Specials