​​Our Menu changes throughout the year but this is a sample of what we have:

Raw Bar - July/August

Fresh Oysters - served with a chipotle mignonette sauce 
Fresh Littleneck Clams on the Half Shell - served with key lime cocktail sauce


Bang Bang Shrimp - Curly shrimp dusted and fried served with a bang bang sauce

Corn Fritter - Corn fritters served with horseradish sauce

Fried Oysters - Served with chipotle dipping sauce

Irish Nachos - Homemade potato chips with bacon, cheese, sour cream and salsa.
Calamari - Fresh calamari sliced and batter dipped served with a spicy marinara sauce

Mussels Meuniere - Mussels steamed in a fresh herb, garlic, and white wine sauce

Lobster Mac n Cheese - Sammys creamy cheese sauce with lobster meat tossed with pasta
Crispy Lobster Salad Tacos - Fresh lobster salad in a crispy wonton shell
Stuffed Mushrooms - Stuffed with fresh herbs and shrimp, scallops, and lobster.
Baked Stuffed Clams - Chopped clams with a bread crumb stuffing.

Chicken Wings - Thai Sweet Chili, Maple Buffalo, Garlic, BBQ, or Teriyaki​

Soup of the Day

Sammy's Fish Chowder
Lobster Bisque
French Onion Soup
New England Clam Chowder in a sour dough boule

Anne's Salad - apples, blueberries, grapes and toasted pecans with a raspberry vinaigrette on mixed greens.
Sammy's Greek Salad - with fresh lettuce, cucumbers, red onions, olives, tomatoes, banana peppers, feta cheese and balsamic vinaigrette

Ceasar Salad - Romaine lettuce with a creamy caesar dressing

The BLT Wedge - Wedge of Iceberg with tomato, bacon and blue cheese dressing

Make it any Salad an Entree - add grilled chicken or popcorn shrimp

Shrimp Po Boy - on a toasted baguette
Crispy Flounder Sandwich - crispy flounder on a toasted bun

Wimpie Burger - half pound burger with lettuce, tomatoes, bacon and cheese.
Chicken ABLT - Grilled chicken breast with avocado, bacon, lettuce and tomato with

                            chipotle aioli. 
Sammy's One and Only Lobster Burger - with lettuce, tomato and avocado
Mary's Famous Lobster Roll - Lobster salad on a potato bun
Impossible Burger - 100% plant based burger with fresh cut fries and cole slaw

Sammy's Soft Tacos - Choice of popcorn shrimp, crispy flounder or grilled chicken

Entrees   (dinner menu only)    

Lazy Man’s Lobster – lobster meat served with butter, fries and cole slaw 

Stuffed Flounder  - served with a creamy lobster sauce, rice and fresh vegetables  
Montauk Fish and Chips - served with homemade coleslaw and tarter sauce

BBQ Baby Back Ribs - served with sweet potato fries and fresh cole slaw 
Grilled NY Steak - cooked to your liking with mashed potatoes and fresh seasonal vegetables 

Panko Crusted Shrimp  - served with fresh-cut fries and cole slaw

Fishermans Platter - crispy panko crusted flounder, sweet clams and popcorn shrimp with fresh-cut fries and cole slaw  
Buttered Lobster Roll - lobster meat drizzled with butter on a toasted roll served with fresh-cut fries and cole slaw   
Sammy's Original Seafood Pasta – pasta served with shrimp, scallops and lobster in a 

tomato cream sauce with fresh basil  
Catch of the Day 

Homemade Fries               Creamy Slaw                Fresh Vegetable Medley        
Sweet Potato Fries       Batter Dipped Onion Rings      


Sammy Burger                           Cheeseburger                            Chicken Fingers
Spaghetti                               Crispy Flounder Fish and Chips    Grilled Cheese

Comes with a choice of French Fries, Garden Salad, Carrots and Dip, or Watermelon Slices
Cold Beverages                                                                      Hot Beverages
Iced Tea                 Milk                                                                           Coffee
Iced coffee            Juice                                                                         Tea
Soda                                                                                                          Expresso

Consuming Raw or Undercooked Meats, Fish, Shellfish or Fresh Shell Eggs May Increase Your Risk of Foodborne Illness. Especially if You Have Certain Medical Conditions.  Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy.

A 20% Gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more.


​​​Restaurant and Bar

448 West Lake Dr.

Montauk, NY 11954



Daily  Specials



Open 5 days a week 

​Closed Wednesday and Thursday

Call us AT:


email us AT: